×
Free Shipping @ Any Price
Best Price GUARANTEE
30 days money back

American Standard vs Trane

Posted by Robert on Jan 20th 2022

American Standard vs Trane

Photo from Magic Touch Mechanical

American Standard and Trane are leading brands in air conditioning. Which is the best choice for you? Here are several factors of the two brands to help you choose the best one for you.

What is common between American Standard and Trane?

American Standard and Trane make similar air conditioner models. They have the same features but the final unit colors and casing are different. Also, the nameplates are different.

Comparing American Standard and Trane

American Standard and Trane Efficiency

Both companies produce the best air conditioners when it comes to efficiency.

Trane XV201 TruComfort variable speed is the most efficient air conditioner. It is built with a SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) of about 22 and 750 stages of comfort for maximum climate regulation.

This system automatically regulates its temperatures and ensures optimum speeds to avoid temperature fluctuations. Trane XV201 is very quiet and offers the lowest cost per minute.

On the other hand, AccuComfort variable-speed Platinum 20 air conditioner is American Standard’s most efficient air conditioner. It comes with a SEER of about 22.

This air conditioner is fitted with a system that automatically regulates to the required speed to provide comfort levels. It works best to lower operating costs and is extremely quiet.

Trane and American Standard Compressors

There is no evident distinction between American Standard and Trane air conditioner compressors. The Platinum series air conditioner compressors from American Standard come with 700 stages and variable speeds. Gold series air conditioners are 2-stage machines while silver series are single-stage.

American Standard and Trane Coils

Most American Standard air conditioners are made of aluminum spine coils, although the Silver 16 Side Discharge is made with a plate-fin coil.

However, the American Standard and the Trane air conditioner coils are similar. Both brands use foil-backed insulation for easy wiping and cleaning.

Trane coils are used for heat pump systems and equipment just like the American Standard AC coils. They offer the best quality and performance, and ensure that all HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) systems perform well for each brand.

American Standard and Trane Warranties

Both American Standard and Trane air conditioner models provide different warranties for different parts. For instance, there is a 10-year warranty on the outdoor coil and a 10-year warranty on the other internal components.

Trane’s XL and True Comfort and American Standard’s Gold Series and AccuComfortunits feature a 12-year warranty on the compressor— a big benefit!

Whichever air conditioner model you choose, ensure your dealer provides the full warranty before the unit is fixed. Also, request for the maintenance manual so you know after how long you should service the machine. Ensure that you don’t compromise your warranty and investment by having the unit installed correctly. This can be done by a well skilled contractor approved by the manufacturer.

American Standard and Trane Air Conditioners

The table below provides a detailed comparison between American Standard and Trane HVAC air conditioners.

The warrant column has two numbers, the first stands for the warranty on the compressor and the second refers to the coil and other parts. The weight is not included in the table since there are many to choose from. The table provides you with a snapshot of various models produced by each company. The contractor handling your installation will advise on which ton is best for your home.

Variable models

Both companies produce two variable units with similar features.

Two-stage models

Both brands have 2-stage units. American Standard has one while Trane has three. American Standard’s two stage machine is only the Gold 17.

Single-stage models

Both models have four single-stage units bearing similar properties. The XR14 single-stage machine is the best for Trane.

Low profile models

Each brand produces a low-profile single-stage model and all have the same features.

Trane and American Standard Air Conditioners Pricing

In terms of pricing and value, we will give you estimated costs. Their reluctance is somewhat understandable since there are many variables. These may range from your house’s size to your installation requirements to climate conditions of your area.

There is one slight cost difference of the DuraTuff top that works on premium model air conditioners—American Standard charges extra while Trane doesn’t. Another factor is that Trane charges a marketing fee.

The pricing below is based on information from Trane website. American Standard does not offer any price information. The price range in the table below is only for a 3-ton unit. Note that the prices are similar between each brand and the range is very wide. Remember, installation costs and the size of the unit will adversely affect the costs as well.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Trane and American Standard?

There is no difference between the air conditioner, or any other cooling and heating equipment produced by these two companies.

Just like any other company, both American Standard and Trane companies offer three air conditioner brands. The Trane includes two additional 2-stage models.

Does Trane cost more than American Standard?

The two models are found at the top end of the scale in the market. Generally, you will notice that the prices range between 3% and 5% of each other. The American Standard price is likely to be higher.

Is American Standard a good HVAC brand?

Yes. American Standard is the best HVAC model. It is one the oldest, and one the best models in the world. The company makes the most reliable, energy-efficient, and long lasting air conditioners.

Its competitors such as Trane and Carrier models also produce high quality HVAC products.

Which could you choose? Trane or American Standard?

When doing this review, we checked hundreds of posts on websites having comparison between these two top brands. However, the highlighted features were similar to the ones we have provided.

Nonetheless, this doesn’t mean it is easier to make a choice between the two. You can always have a skilled contractor help you out. Ensure that the HVAC dealer you contract has enough experience and legal documents such as license and insurance. Whichever model you choose, chances are the equipment will take about 10-12 years without maintenance. Thereafter, you should replace the air conditioner.

Final Thoughts

Looking at the two brands, you will notice that there is little to differentiate them. The only difference may be seen during installation of the unit where the contractor will decide on the type of installation. Therefore, to get the best out of your American Standard and Trane HVAC system, look for a reliable HVAC dealer for your new purchase.

We carry a variety of high-quality home improvement products. Find what you need here!

Robert Syengo is an experienced web writer with a home improvement history that includes toilet remodeling and appliance installation. He enjoys writing and learning about electronics, gardens, design, remodeling and repair.

to top